Not really sure I understand your hostility towards DCDA - unless it's simply a hobby to stand on the sidelines and comment rather than rolling up your sleeves and getting your hands dirty. I'm new to UP, but not new to libel and slander. If that's what this thread is really all about, you won't see any credible discussions on future posts. This could be a very powerful and perhaps valuable forum for the community. But if personal vendettas superceed well thought out dialogue, we can kiss this outlet goodbye. That said - I'll just encourage you to get involved with the projects in the community - the real community, not the virtual community. You seem to make some very good observations and might offer great insight into the develoment of future projects. Dilworth has changed immensly in the past 5 years - as have the people who are leading it into the next 5. I'm glad you agree with some DCDA decisions, and I hope you will become more actively involved day to day. Each project brings its own set of intricacies. It's okay to disagree, as long as you're standing there putting forth the effort with the common goal of achieving the very highest and best use.
For the facts - Catellus had a public hearing last night in front of the DCDA Land Use Committee. They're working with HDC to comply with their fenestration guidelines. In fact, because of the "fight, fight, fight" message, these guys have agreed that wood siding and windows are probably the best direction to go (and gain support) for their project. Obviously materials aren't the only issue - scale, massing, and the loss of two more contributing structures within the historic district are not to be overlooked. The full board hasn't heard the project yet, but the Land Use group I heard last night had no problem with the overall use. A hotel, done appropriately, could be a great benefit / addition to the neighborhood. I hope this project will receive support from the community.
Last thought - TreHouse is well within Dilworth and clearly inside the border of the Historic District of the neighborhood. In fact, Dilworth used to be marked by the train tracks as it's westen border. How things have changed.