I comepletely see what you are saying.. However, do you not agree that in Charlotte many of the newer developments, especially when an entire area is renovated and revitalized, see the popular chains pioneer the clean slate which has just been constructed. I.E. Midtown (metropolitan), Phillips place, Birkdale, Sharon Corners, Epicenter (planned so far). Because the firstward area has been 'clean slated' id say it falls into this category.
Dont get me wrong, YOU both are right in your statements that the cache of the admired Georgetown full of upscale retail attraction, constant flow of pedstrians/visitors, and meer physical attraction are not by accident and didnt not happen over night. It is a result of good design that compliments flow of traffic, (ha! ya right... but seriously) reasonable and attractive retail space and presentation, and multiuse structures that can serve as either or both at the same time.
Realistically, 1st Ward we will never recreate such a magnificent relic of residential, retail, and architectural grace. We ARE the new, stucco covered, quick fab, rushed design, build and keep moving type of city. And part of this fault falls just with the times we are in and the technology we have. If we were in 1800s and had only brick, then our architecure would resemble much more of that sturdy CLASSIC utilitarian feel which most would agree summarizes Gtown's architecture to a T.
But can we not steer away from the trend that GATEWAY VILLAGE went down?
Residential above (forgive my diction and narrow minded thought process) pointless retail: Nail Salons, Convience Stores, inpersonal restaurants that fail months later, and random other light commercial space that isnt enought to ever convert to anything of significance or uniqueness.
I would like to see a community which is not a false conjecture of a cookie cutter "modern village", instead a place more along the lines of(shall i stay with the DC/VA reference) Clarendon, Courthouse, Balston of NoVa. Where the urban feel is aligned with quality retail space and design so that access to most any and everything you want and need is with in a square 1/2 miles.
Anyon feel me on this reconsidered theory of 1st Ward's potential? Explain, expand, correct my naiveness